St. Lucie County commissioners on Nov. 10 turned down a future land-use change for about 34 acres near South 25th Street and West Midway Road, on a 3-2 vote, with drainage and recent flooding hanging over the discussion (via CBS12). The change would have allowed up to 15 homes per acre, which works out to nearly 500 homes.
County staff had recommended approval, with adjustments meant to limit impacts on wetlands and required buffers. A majority of the board voted no anyway. CBS12 didn't name the applicant.
The sticking point was water. An engineer told the board the property takes runoff from roughly 134 acres and sends it to nearby canals through a single 24-inch pipe, and that a second pipe might be needed. The site also sits lower than the roads around it, so it would have to be filled and raised before anything could be built. That raised the worry that new pads would push water onto neighbors.
The timing didn't help the request. The vote came about a week after a storm that county officials estimated dropped 12 to 16 inches of rain, with more in some spots. At a Nov. 3 briefing, the county reported 120 high-water rescues and water-related calls, and interim County Administrator Mayté Santamaria warned it could take several days for the water to go down, CBS12 reported.
Creekside, a neighborhood of about 150 homes off State Road 70 west of Florida's Turnpike, was among the hardest hit. WPTV reported that roughly three-quarters of its homes had been evacuated and power was shut off while floodwater stood knee-deep in parts of the community.
Residents from Creekside and White City showed up at the same Nov. 10 meeting. According to CBS12, Creekside residents asked for an engineering review of the neighborhood and its watershed, a new look at flood risk and a mitigation plan with deadlines. White City residents described repeat flooding and asked for drainage upgrades and more stormwater storage. One said her home and yard had flooded four times since 2012.
WPBF, which also covered the meeting, reported residents pressing for better retention and drainage. "We don't need another explanation on how historic this rainfall was. We need to make sure this never happens again," one resident said.
Commissioners also made official an emergency declaration covering flooded roads and strained drainage systems. The county is separately collecting flood damage reports from residents, businesses and farm owners through an online survey that runs through Nov. 20, WPTV reported.
Why it matters for Contractors
One denial doesn't change county policy, but it shows where the bar is right now. A low site that needs fill, takes in water from surrounding land and drains through limited pipe is going to get a hard look, even with a staff recommendation behind it.
For site work, drainage and underground utility contractors on the Treasure Coast, expect stormwater design to sit closer to the center of projects after this storm, and expect more questions at hearings about where the water goes. If the county follows through on what residents asked for, drainage studies and improvements in places like Creekside and White City could also lead to public work down the line, though nothing has been budgeted or put out to bid yet. Builders weighing land in low-lying parts of the county should build extra time for drainage review into their schedules.