A Miami construction company owner is facing felony charges after state investigators say he hid close to a million dollars in payroll from his workers' comp carrier and paid a fraction of the premium he owed. Florida Chief Financial Officer Blaise Ingoglia announced the arrest of Israel Carballo on Nov. 10 (via Florida Department of Financial Services).
Investigators with the department's Criminal Investigations Division arrested Carballo on Nov. 5. The state says he underreported payroll to his insurer and concealed payroll when he applied for coverage, which kept his premium low.
The numbers in the state's case are specific. According to the department, Carballo had $968,278.71 in unreported payroll exposure, and he ran $1,074,278.71 in checks through money service businesses, the check-cashing shops, to keep that payroll off the insurer's radar. He paid $9,297.43 in premium for the policy year. The state puts the insurer's loss at $100,565.57.
He's charged with grand theft, organized scheme to defraud and workers' compensation fraud. The Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office is prosecuting. These are allegations, and Carballo hasn't been convicted of anything.
Insurance Journal, working from the arrest affidavit and court records, reported that the company is Carballo Group LLC and the insurer is NorGuard, a Berkshire Hathaway company. The outlet reported that Carballo bought the policy in 2023 and reported few workers, that an investigator subpoenaed subcontractor records showing roughly $1.07 million paid to workers, and that the correct annual premium would have been $109,863. It also reported that Carballo pleaded not guilty and was released on bond.
"These crimes result in higher premiums for the honest businesses trying to keep their doors open, and I will not stand for that to happen," Ingoglia said in the release.
The check-cashing method shows up again and again in the state's premium fraud cases. In March, the department announced the arrest of a Martin County man accused of using two money service businesses to hide payroll, costing his insurer $1,090,504 in premium over two years. In April, it announced the arrest of a Jacksonville-area construction business owner accused of reporting $25,000 in payroll on a policy while paying about $2 million, a $299,458 premium shortfall.
The math is why the state cares. When a contractor pays crews in cash or through check cashers and leaves them off the books, the premium on that labor never gets paid, and the losses get spread across everyone else's rates.
Florida's construction rules are stricter than most industries'. According to the state Division of Workers' Compensation, construction employers must carry coverage once they have one employee, and owners who are corporate officers or LLC members count. Outside construction, the threshold is four employees.
Officers can opt out with a construction exemption, but only if they own at least 10% of an active corporation or LLC, and no more than three officers per company can be exempt. An exempt officer can't collect benefits if he's hurt.
Subs matter too. The division says a contractor has to confirm that subcontractors have coverage before work starts. If a sub doesn't have it, the sub's workers become the contractor's employees for comp purposes, and the contractor pays the benefits.
Hiding payroll carries its own penalties apart from any criminal case. Under state law, the department can issue a stop-work order to employers that understate or conceal payroll, which shuts down all of that business's operations in Florida. The penalty is twice what the employer should have paid in premium, looking back up to 24 months for employers that concealed payroll.
Why it matters for Contractors
If you're running a small crew in Florida, the takeaway is simple: report your real payroll and tell your carrier when it grows. An audit or a subpoena of your sub payments can turn an underpriced policy into a stop-work order, a big penalty and possibly criminal charges.
Get a certificate of insurance or a valid exemption from every sub before they step on your site, and keep copies. If they're not covered, their crew is on your policy whether you planned for it or not.
Paying people in cash or through check cashers and calling them subs is exactly what investigators look for. If a sub is really an employee, treat him that way.
And if you're bidding against someone whose numbers only work because they skip comp, the state takes tips. The Insurance Fraud Hotline is 1-800-378-0445, and tips can also be filed online through the department's Fraud Free Florida page.