Issues The Feed
Hello Contractor News

Construction jobs stall in October as residential shops cut 16,400 workers

October construction jobs were flat as residential firms cut 16,400 workers while wages rose 5.2%. What the tight labor pool means for small contractors now.

Framers at work on a house under construction. Photo: NIOSH (public domain)

Construction employment barely moved in October, but the split underneath it was sharp. Nonresidential contractors kept hiring while residential builders and trade contractors cut 16,400 jobs, according to an analysis of new federal jobs data by the Associated General Contractors of America (via AGC).

The industry employed 8,367,000 people in October, AGC said, down 3,000 from a revised September figure but up 124,000, or 1.5%, from a year earlier. The Bureau of Labor Statistics' monthly jobs report, released Nov. 6, put construction among several industries that showed little change over the month, after a 16,000-job gain in September. Overall, employers added 165,000 jobs, and the national unemployment rate was 4.1%.

All of construction's growth over the past year came from the nonresidential side. Those contractors added 13,300 jobs in October and 164,600, or 3.3%, over 12 months. Residential builders and specialty trade contractors went the other way, losing 40,200 jobs, or 1.2%, over the same stretch.

NAHB economist Jing Fu, writing on the builders group's Eye On Housing blog, called October's residential drop the largest monthly decline since March 2021. It was also the 20th straight month that residential construction employment was down from a year earlier. Fu counted about 3.3 million residential construction workers, including 921,000 at builders and remodelers and roughly 2.3 million at residential specialty trade contractors.

Pay kept climbing anyway. Average hourly earnings for production and nonsupervisory construction workers, the people doing most of the hands-on work, rose to $39.70. That's up 5.2% from a year ago and 21.2% above the $32.75 average for all private-sector production workers, whose pay grew 3.3%. AGC's release doesn't break out residential pay separately.

The pool of available workers is also thin. AGC said 363,000 jobseekers had recent construction experience, the lowest October count since 2018. Their unemployment rate was 3.6%, not seasonally adjusted, tying 2018 for the lowest October rate in the series' 27-year history.

Put together, that's an odd picture: residential firms are trimming crews, yet few experienced construction workers are out looking for work. AGC frames the problem as a shortage of people, not demand. "Nonresidential contractors are adding employees and raising hourly pay at rates far exceeding the broader economy," said Ken Simonson, the association's chief economist. He warned that keeping those gains going will be hard unless contractors can bring in workers who already have the right experience.

"Contractors are eager to hire more workers," said Jeffrey D. Shoaf, AGC's chief executive officer. He said that means policymakers need to expand training, pursue immigration reforms and keep federal funding flowing.

AGC is asking Congress for more money for career training programs, a way for contractors to sponsor qualified workers from outside the U.S., and a new highway and transit funding bill before federal money runs out in December. The full employment table is posted on AGC's site.

Why it matters for Contractors

For small residential shops, October's numbers cut both ways. Job losses on the housing side mean some experienced hands may be looking, but with construction unemployment near a record low for the month, don't count on a deep bench of applicants. Nonresidential contractors are hiring and paying well, and they're competing for the same carpenters, electricians and laborers you are.

If you have good people, keeping them is cheaper than replacing them. Make sure your pay and scheduling hold up against what commercial outfits nearby are offering, and build wage increases into bids. A 5% annual jump in labor costs adds up quickly on a fixed-price job that runs several months.

If you also take on light commercial or tenant-improvement work, the numbers suggest that side of the market is the one still adding jobs, which may be worth leaning into while housing stays soft.