An Augusta County circuit judge on Nov. 10 found realtor Amy Argenbright guilty of two felony counts of construction fraud, tied to two custom homes that clients paid hundreds of thousands of dollars for and never got (via Augusta Free Press).
Judge Shannon Sherrill issued the verdict after a two-day bench trial and about two weeks of deliberation. Sentencing is set for Feb. 23, 2027, and the judge granted the defense's request for a presentence report. Argenbright, who owns A&Co 2002 LLC, remains free on bond. Each count carries up to 20 years in prison under Virginia law.
The case centered on two projects. Candy Burchett, a retired federal IT employee, advanced more than $245,000 for a roughly 1,700-square-foot home in the Valley Manor subdivision west of Staunton. She ended up with an unfinished foundation and no lumber on site. At trial in October, the judge described it this way: "She (Burchett) paid a quarter of a million dollars and wound up with three foundation walls."
David Weigley paid $366,000 for a home on Entry School Road in eastern Augusta County. When he sent a demand letter in October 2024, the house was a shell with no windows, drywall or cabinets. Augusta County builder Kevin Lacey later finished it at Weigley's request, at a cost of about $428,000 more, according to the Augusta Free Press.
The money trail mattered. Prosecutors showed that a payment of nearly $52,000 Weigley made in June 2023 went partly to Argenbright's overdue mortgage, with more than $19,000 sent to First Bank & Trust. A bank manager testified the loan was seven months behind. Large deposits from both clients also moved from the business account into a personal account Argenbright shares with her husband, Eric. "The money was applied to delinquent loans," Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney Caleb Kramer told the court.
The defense argued the Weigley dispute was a civil matter, said a crew was on site when the company was ordered off the job, and blamed the delay on electrical service not being provided. Eric Argenbright testified he holds a Class A contractor's license and has "built hundreds and hundreds of homes and never walked away." Defense attorney Thomas Weidner IV said in a statement that his client "got in over her head."
The judge said intent was the key question and found that Argenbright's records showed incompetence and fraudulent intent at the same time: "both can be true." The ruling described "a string of broken promises and obfuscation toward each victim."
The case started with a Sheriff's Office investigation into A&Co 2002 LLC in September 2024. A grand jury indicted Argenbright in July 2025 on the Weigley count, Rocktown Now reported at the time, and she was arrested and released on an unsecured bond. Two more indictments followed in November 2025, one involving Burchett and one involving a third client, Keldon Koblick. Only the Weigley and Burchett counts were decided Nov. 10.
The charge comes from Va. Code § 18.2-200.1. It applies when someone takes an advance of money "with fraudulent intent" on a promise to build or improve a structure, fails to do the work and doesn't substantially return the money. It kicks in only if the advance isn't returned within 15 days of a request sent by certified mail, return receipt requested. A conviction is treated as larceny, which makes it a felony when $1,000 or more is involved.
Why it matters for Contractors
This case is a reminder that Virginia treats taking a deposit and not doing the work as theft, not just a contract dispute, once a client sends that 15-day certified letter and the money isn't made good. If a job goes sideways, how you handle that letter matters.
The bigger lesson is about draws. Clients here paid large sums well ahead of the work in place. For a small shop, tying each draw to completed, inspected stages protects the customer and protects you. It keeps cash on the job it was paid for, and it gives you a clean paper trail if a dispute ever lands in court.
Keep client money separate. Moving deposits into personal accounts or using them to cover old debts was central to the intent finding here. A dedicated job account and simple draw records can make the difference between a civil fight and a criminal case.