A lawsuit Michigan's home builders filed against the City of Troy back in 2010 is finally over, and the result gives builders across the state a clearer line on what a city can charge for building permits (via NAHB).
The Home Builders Association of Michigan, which litigated the case under its former name, the Michigan Association of Home Builders, argued that Troy was charging more for permits and inspections than it cost to run its building department, then using the extra money elsewhere. According to the National Association of Home Builders, which helped pay for the case through its Legal Action Fund, a settlement was reached this year. HBAM recently returned $89,000 to that fund as its share of the proceeds.
Here's how it started. After the housing crash of the late 2000s, Troy handed its permit work to a private company. That firm collected the fees and did the inspections, and sent up to 25% of each permit fee back to the city to cover the building department's direct and indirect costs. The builders said the city was spending that money on things outside the building department.
Michigan's construction code law requires building fees to bear a reasonable relation to the cost of the services they pay for. The builders also argued the excess amounted to a tax that voters never approved, in violation of the state's Headlee Amendment.
The case bounced between courts for years. In 2015, the Michigan Supreme Court ruled the builders didn't have to go through a state administrative process before suing. In 2019, the same court sided with the builders on the fee question, finding Troy couldn't use building fees to make up for building department shortfalls from earlier years. "MCL 125.1522(1) does not envision a 'surplus' baked consistently into the fees," the justices wrote. According to the court record, Troy kept $269,483 in 2012, $488,922 in 2013 and $325,512 in 2014.
After a two-day bench trial, Oakland County Circuit Judge David Cohen ruled on Feb. 2, 2023, that Troy's fees broke the construction code law, but he found the builders lacked standing on the Headlee claim. The Michigan Court of Appeals reversed that part in October 2024, holding the association had standing and that the fees were an unlawful tax under Headlee.
"The wheels of justice don't always move fast, but they've finally moved in this case," HBAM CEO Bob Filka told C&G Newspapers after the appeals ruling.
On its own website, HBAM says Troy paid the association $575,000, which it describes as the legal fees owed to a winning plaintiff in a Headlee case. HBAM also says it is now contacting other Michigan cities and townships it believes charge excessive permit fees, sending them the final Troy decision, and asking local builder associations to flag jurisdictions in their areas.
NAHB says its Legal Action Fund is taking new grant applications, with decisions to be made at the International Builders' Show in 2027.
Why it matters for Contractors
If you build or remodel in Michigan, this case is the reference point for permit fees. The courts have now said a city can't build a standing surplus into its building fees or use them to cover costs outside the building department, and that overcharges can count as an illegal tax.
That doesn't mean your local fees are wrong. But if your town has raised permit or inspection fees, it's fair to ask how the new rates tie to what the building department actually spends. Fee studies and budgets are generally public records.
You don't have to fight it alone, either. HBAM is asking members and local associations to report jurisdictions with fee structures that look out of line, and a local HBA can raise it on your behalf. For builders outside Michigan, the case is a reminder that permit fee rules are set by state law, and worth reading before the next fee hike lands.