Issues The Feed
Hello Contractor News

Graham council unanimously rejects White Rock Estates, the city's first proposed gated subdivision

Graham's council voted 5-0 to deny White Rock Estates, a 24-home gated cottage and ranch subdivision near Hanford Road, after three rounds of revisions.

Alamance County Courthouse in downtown Graham, N.C. Photo: Warren LeMay via Wikimedia Commons (Flickr), CC0

Graham's city council has turned down White Rock Estates, a 24-home gated subdivision planned for about 10 acres near Hanford Road and West Moore Street (via Alamance News). The 5-0 vote came Tuesday, Nov. 10, and ends a rezoning fight that's been running since spring. It would have been the first gated neighborhood in the city.

The project was led by Michael Watkins, a developer from Troy, Ohio, who has said he planned to live in the community himself. A site survey in the city's agenda packet lists the property owner as WACA Properties LLC.

The final plan called for 15 cottage homes of 900 to 1,200 square feet and nine custom ranch-style homes of 1,200 to 2,500 square feet. Lots would have been roughly 3,000 square feet. The cottages would have sat on the west side of an existing pond and the ranch homes on the east side, with the pond and much of the woods kept as open space. Watkins put the investment at about $12 million and pitched the homes to active adults. He'd told the planning board earlier that they'd sell for around $350,000, but he didn't give a price at the council meeting.

The land is zoned R-18, the city's low-density single-family district, and Watkins asked to move it to C-R, or Conditional Residential, according to the city's staff report. Watkins and his engineer, Chad Huffine of Burlington, argued that the site could justify about 18 houses under current zoning if the pond were filled in, and that clustering homes around it was the better use. City planning staff agreed the request fit the Suburban Residential area in the Graham 2035 Comprehensive Plan.

It took three tries to get to a council vote. An April planning board packet shows a first version with 27 homes, 17 of them described as tiny homes. A 26-home version drew a 4-0 recommendation for denial from the planning board in May. The developer then cut the count to 24 and dropped a second entrance that would have crossed a corner of a neighbor's property. In September the planning board flipped and recommended approval, adding conditions for an 8-foot privacy fence along the neighboring property lines and around the pump station, plus a turnaround in front of the gate. The council hearing was continued three times before Tuesday's vote.

Sewer service was one sticking point. The staff report shows the homes would connect to a private on-site pump station, with a private force main tying into city sewer in Moore Street or Hanford Road, and the homeowners association maintaining it. Residents raised odor concerns, and Mayor Pro Tem Ricky Hall worried the city could end up taking it over.

Council member Bonnie Whitaker, who made the motion to deny, said she had a "lot of concerns," pointing to traffic, the pump station and a deed restriction on the property. That restriction reportedly sets a minimum house size of 2,500 square feet. Watkins said his attorneys told him the plan complies. City planner Cameron West said in August that the deed question is a private matter between the former and current owners, Alamance News reported.

Councilman Bobby Chin told the developer, "You're squeezing more homes" in than the current zoning intended, and he raised "the potential precedent it would set for other developers." Mayor Chelsea Dickey asked about parking, citing another approved subdivision where cars in driveways block sidewalks. Watkins said each home would have a carport or garage and room for two cars in the driveway.

Neighbors, including Mildred Huey, 93, who lives next to the site, spoke against the plan. Her granddaughter, Ivey Archer, said it would "fundamentally change the character of this neighborhood."

Why it matters for Contractors

There's no job here now, and the Alamance News story doesn't say whether the developer plans another try. The useful part for small builders is what the vote says about selling density-for-open-space infill in Graham.

On paper this project did a lot right. Planning staff found it consistent with the comprehensive plan, the planning board ended up recommending it, and the developer revised it twice to answer complaints. It still lost 5-0, mostly on how many homes were going onto how little land, plus a private pump station and a deed dispute. If you're working up a cottage or small-lot plan in a neighborhood of larger single-family lots, expect a council to weigh neighbors' objections on fit and traffic heavily, and expect private sewer infrastructure and any deed restrictions to get hard questions. Settling those early, and talking to adjacent owners before the first hearing, is cheaper than three rounds of redesign.