Issues The Feed
Hello Contractor News

Weston duplex owners line up to split units into condos, and the village is tightening the paperwork

Weston, Wis., is seeing a wave of requests to split duplexes into condos. A Carter Ave. case shows the escrow, termination and consent rules the village wants.

Weston Village Hall in Marathon County, Wisconsin. Photo: Wikideas1 via Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

Owners of side-by-side duplexes in the Village of Weston keep asking the same question: can we sell each half on its own? Enough of them are asking that village staff are writing checklists to explain the options (via Wausau Pilot & Review).

"We're getting so many requests for it," village staff told the Plan Commission, according to the Pilot & Review. "So this won't be the last one we see." Staff received another request the Friday before the meeting, for a duplex built in 2003.

The latest case is a duplex at 3404 and 3406 Carter Ave. On Nov. 9, the Plan Commission recommended conditional approval of a condominium plat, declaration and bylaws that would turn it into two separately owned units. The item goes next to the Village Board.

Here's why owners end up at condos. Many try a zero-lot-line split first, drawing a new lot line down the shared wall. Weston's rules for zero-lot-line two-family homes require real separation: a code-required fire-rated wall between units, separate sewer and water laterals and meters, and a recorded common-wall maintenance agreement that can't be changed without Village Board approval. A lot of older duplexes weren't built that way. When they don't qualify, a condo plat under Wisconsin's condominium law is the alternative.

That's what happened on Carter Avenue. The owners first tried a zero-lot-line split. Review of that request turned up an unpermitted 12-by-20-foot shed, since moved under a permit, and a fence on the wrong part of the property that's being moved to the west line.

Under the proposed condo documents, each unit has 1,727 square feet of living space and a 50% share of the common elements, including the roof, the foundation and the shared wall. A two-member association, one director per unit, would run it.

The documents fell short of village code in three places, according to the staff report by Planning and Development Director Jennifer Higgins. The code requires a mandatory escrow or reserve for shared repairs; the Carter Avenue declaration made reserves optional. The code requires a voluntary termination process; the documents only covered a decision not to rebuild after a casualty. And the code requires Village Board consent before those protections can be changed; the documents let the two owners amend them on their own.

Approval is conditioned on fixing those gaps, updating the plat to show the shed, fence and common areas, meeting state plat rules, and recording the plat with the Marathon County Register of Deeds. Village rules also bar related permits until the plat is recorded.

A commissioner asked what happens if the two owners deadlock. Staff said the condo documents govern disputes and the village stays out of them. Staff also said some older Weston condos lack proper documents, which has caused trouble when one owner wants to replace half of a roof that really needs to be done all at once.

Why it matters for Contractors

If you remodel or reroof duplexes in the Wausau area, expect more of these jobs to come with two owners and an association attached. That changes who signs the contract. On a shared roof, foundation or party wall, you may need both owners, or the association, to approve the work and the payment, and the reserve account the village now requires is where that money is supposed to come from.

Before you bid a half-roof or a party-wall repair on a converted duplex, ask for the condo declaration. It should say what's a common element, who decides and who pays. If the documents are thin, that's a warning sign the job could stall when the neighbor disagrees.

For builders putting up new two-family homes, the zero-lot-line rules are worth designing for up front. A true fire-rated separation wall and separate utility laterals give future owners a clean path to sell each side on its own, which can make the building easier to sell.