A Tarrant County jury has ordered a Fort Worth-area builder to pay more than $21.6 million to a family whose home, their lawyers say, filled with sewer gas because the plumbing vents stopped in the attic instead of running out through the roof (via Just Well Law). The verdict, which includes $10 million in exemplary damages, came Oct. 13 after a trial that started Oct. 5 in the 67th District Court.
The case is Ronny and Mandy McCoy, individually and on behalf of their child, against NAE Enterprises Inc., which does business as NAE Contracting. According to the family's attorneys at Austin-based Just Well Law, jurors deliberated for about two hours before reaching their decision.
Most of what's public about the case comes from the plaintiffs' side, so the details below are their account and the jury's findings as their lawyers reported them. None of the sources reviewed for this story included a response from NAE.
According to the firm, the McCoys raised concerns about an odor before they closed on the house in 2018. A plumber later found that the vents had been terminated in the attic, which let sewer gas circulate through the living space. The lawyers also say the foundation wasn't fully sealed, which led to moisture, mold and insects.
The family eventually left the house on the advice of the Texas State Board of Plumbing Examiners, the firm said. They now live in an RV on the property and describe the house as uninhabitable. Their lawyers say family members have dealt with migraines, breathing and skin problems, dizziness and other health issues, claims that were part of the case.
The jury found NAE liable on several counts, according to the release: a knowing and intentional violation of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, breach of implied warranty, negligence, negligent hiring and supervision, and gross negligence. The gross negligence finding and the exemplary damages award were unanimous.
Jurors assigned NAE 77% of the responsibility. Dauenhauer & Associates and Ricky Dauenhauer were each assigned 10%. The release calls NAE the final remaining defendant and doesn't say what role the Dauenhauers played on the job or who accounts for the remaining share.
"Every family who hires a builder is counting on the same thing: that their home will be built safely and to code," Just Well Law attorney Sabine Wakim said in the release. Attorney Maggie Neusel said "the safety of the families who live in these homes must come before profits, shortcuts, or indifference." Kristina Baehr also represented the family.
The release doesn't mention post-trial motions or an appeal, and verdicts this size are often challenged or reduced after trial. What gets collected can be very different from what a jury awards.
Why it matters for Contractors
A vent that stops in the attic is a cheap shortcut that's easy to miss once the insulation goes in, and in this case the jury tied it to an eight-figure judgment. A few takeaways for small builders and remodelers:
Check vent terminations yourself before the attic gets insulated, even when a sub handles the plumbing. The jury found the builder liable for negligent hiring and supervision, a sign that pointing at the sub may not get a builder off the hook.
Take odor and moisture complaints seriously, especially before closing. The family's lawyers say the McCoys flagged the smell before they ever got the keys. Write down what the customer reported, what you checked and what you fixed.
Know that the DTPA raises the stakes. A finding that a violation was knowing and intentional opens the door to much bigger damages than an ordinary warranty claim. If a customer flags a problem, investigate and respond in writing rather than letting it sit.